The impact of the Brown decision was felt almost immediately in South Carolina. Recognizing the opening created by the verdict, state NAACP officials sought a test case to expand the application of the ruling beyond schools to other areas of daily life.

On June 24, 1954, Sarah Mae Flemming, a young African American domestic worker, boarded a bus operated by South Carolina Electric and Gas Company. On that morning, the bus was crowded, and blacks were forced to stand in the aisle to accommodate white passengers. When a seat became vacant near the front, Flemming sat down. The driver demanded she move to the back. Flemming moved to comply but violated racial custom by attempting to exit the front of the bus because the rear was crowded. The driver struck and ejected Flemming from the bus on the corner of Main and Washington streets.

With the aid of the NAACP, Flemming filed a lawsuit. In Sarah Mae Flemming v. South Carolina Electric and Gas Company, Flemming’s lawyers argued that the state’s existing statutes mandating segregated seating denied Flemming’s right to equal protection under the 14th Amendment and the recently rendered Brown verdict. After an unfavorable decision in South Carolina District Court, Flemming’s legal team issued an appeal. On July 14, 1955, the U.S. Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the principle applied schools in the Brown decision could be expanded to public transportation, and by extension other public accommodations. The court could not rule on the question of damages and sent the case back to South Carolina District Court. After a prolonged campaign of intimidation, which included the burning of a cross on the front lawn of the home of Flemming’s lead attorney, an all-white male jury eventually ruled that SCE&G was not guilty of any wrongdoing. While she received no compensation and eventually faded from the public spotlight, Flemming’s heroic actions provided as an important legal precedent for the Montgomery Bus Boycott, inspired by the globally recognized activist Rosa Parks.

Those in the picture: Left to right: Lincoln C. Jenkins, Sarah Mae Flemming, an unidentified witness, Matthew J. Perry on the steps of the Federal Courthouse following the civil trial of June 1956.  The photograph was taken by John Goodwin.  Image courtesy of South Carolina Library, University of South Carolina, Columbia